New York Surrogate's Court September 15, 1900 (In re the Estate of Mills)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-09-1900
Silkman, S.
This is an appeal from a decree dated June 13, 1900, entered upon the report of an appraiser, assessing the transfer tax upon the succession to the estate of Maria F. Mills, deceased.
Maria F. Mills was the daughter of William Abendroth. The will of Mr. Abendroth directed the sale of his real property, and it thus became in equity personalty.
*609His daughter, Mrs. Mills, under his will took a share in the proceeds of the realty.
She survived her father a few years, but died before an actual sale and conversion had taken place.
Mrs. Mills left a will by which her interest in her father’s •estate passed to her husband, John F. Mills, the respondent here.
The appraiser has held that the interests passing to Mr. Mills under the will of his wife was real estate, and the transfer to him consequently was not taxable. He seems to have felt that the rule adopted in Matter of Sutton, 15 Misc. Rep. 659, 3 App. Div. 208 (which matter originated in this court), controls the disposition of this ease.
It was determined in the Sutton case that where the property passing from the testator was real estate and became personalty only by the equitable rule growing out of the direction to sell, it was not to be considered personal property for the purpose of taxation, but, according to the fact as it was at the time of the death of the testator, real estate. The reasoning followed that adopted in the case of Hoyt v. Commissioners of Taxes, 23 N. Y. 228, that laws providing a system of taxation were to be construed as relating to facts not legal fictions or equitable rules.
The Transfer Tax Law assesses the tax upon the transfer " from ” the testator, and, therefore, it is the character which the property bears at the time that it leaves the testator, which' is to govern the question as to whether the succession to it is taxable.
Brown, P. J.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit