Superior Court of Pennsylvania July 26, 1900, Appeal, No. 19 (Commonwealth v. Shoemaker)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-07-1900

Opinion by

W. D. Portee, J.,

The indictment in this case charged the defendant with erect*202ing and maintaining a public nuisance in the form of a building in a public highway in the village of Clarkstown, Lycoming county. The commonwealth produced evidence which clearly established that John Opp, being then the owner of a large tract of land, in the year 1860 caused the said tract to be surveyed and plotted and laid out into lots fronting upon streets and alleys running over the land. In 1866 John Opp died, having first made his last will and testament, in which he referred to the said plan of lots and devised certain of the lots, designated by numbers upon the plan, to his daughter Phoebe, and in the description of the boundaries of said lots called for a frontage upon the fifty feet wide street, which is the subject of this controversy. The remainder of the tract he devised to his daughter Charlotte, who, in 1867, sold a part fronting upon the southern side of the street to Jared Dewald, and conveyed the same by a deed calling for a frontage upon this fifty feet street. This street, fifty feet wide, was at that time actually opened upon the ground for public travel. It was fenced upon each side and its lines thus clearly defined from end to end, extending from one public road to another, except at a point near the end of the street most distant from defendant’s premises, where the street was to some extent narrowed because of buildings upon a lot which John Opp had sold before dedicating the street. The defendant has acquired title to his premises through Jared Dewald, by conveyances, all of which call for this street as a boundary. Jared Dewald testified that at the time he bought he caused his buildings to be placed at the established line of the fifty foot street and placed a board fence upon his side of the street, clearly defining its limits.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.