Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court March 2, 1900 (Greene v. Damrell)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-03-1900

Barker, J.

The respondent, as building commissioner, is in charge of the department of the city government- of Boston > known as the building department. St. 1895, c. 449, § 24. His official powers and duties are defined in a series of statutes which reguláte the construction, alteration, and inspection of buildings in the city. See Sts. 1892, c. 419 ; 1893, cc. 170, 293, 464 ; 1894, cc. 257, 443; 1895, cc. 97, 239, 280, 314; 1896, cc. 416, 520; 1897, cc. 175, 300, 310, 413; 1898, cc. 209, 228, *395284, 308; 1899, cc. 161, 185. These statutes forbid the alteration of a building without a permit from the respondent. The petitioner has a building which he desires to alter. The respondent has refused a permit, and the court is asked to order him to issue one.

The statutes cited contain numerous and minute directions as to materials, plan, and construction, and also many provisions which leave the decision as to what shall be done to the judgment of the respondent. Anticipating tha't many instances would arise in which the commissioner would differ from parties interested as to the construction of the law, or as to what good judgment might require in matters left to the discretion of officials, the Legislature has provided, for the revision of the respondent’s action in granting or refusing permits, a tribunal known as the board of appeal, consisting of three persons, each selected by a different body of citizens, with the approval of the mayor. St. 1892, c. 419, §§ 12-14. St. 1893, c. 464, § 1. St. 1894, c. 443, § 2. When refused a permit, the petitioner had a right to appeal to this tribunal, and he has exercised that right. Upon such an appeal there is a hearing, and after the hearing the board of appeal is required by the statutes cited to direct the commissioner either to issue the permit under such conditions as the board requires, or to withhold the permit. After an appeal resulting in a direction to withhold the permit the com-.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.