Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court June 20, 1900 (Clapp v. Wilder)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-06-1900

Hammond, J.

This case turns upon the legal force and effect of this clause in the deed from Eaton to the defendants, namely, “ And this conveyance is made upon the express condition that said Wilder and Hills, their heirs and assigns, shall never erect any building nearer the street line of said land than the store building now thereon.”

The first question is whether this is a common law condition. The deed is in the ordinary form of a warranty deed in general use in this Commonwealth, is carefully drawn, and it bears upon its face evidence that the draftsman understood the meaning of the legal terms used.

It conveys in apt language the land now owned by the defendants, and creates also, in express terms, two easements, one of which is a right of way over a strip of land eight feet wide on the grantor’s land next southerly of and adjoining the land conveyed, and the other is the right to maintain a drain from the store building as conveyed to the grantor by a prior deed ; and it reserves a right of way over a strip of land upon the southerly side of the land_conveyed, making, in connection with the right of way above conveyed to the defendants, a passageway sixteen feet wide to be used in common, and also the right to maintain a certain drain from the cellar of the house where the grantor resides to the cellar under said store building.

*335Up to this point the grantor has used language apt to create easements and reservations. He desires to do one thing more, and that is to prevent the erection of any building within a certain distance of the street. Everything else has been provided for. Here the language changes, and, as to this one thing, the deed is upon the express condition that this provision be complied with.

The language is “ upon the express condition,” an emphatic form of the expression “ on condition.” Whatever may be the force of this language in a will (see Attorney General v. Wax Chandlers’ Co. L. R. 6 H. L. 1; Bradstreet v. Clark, 21 Pick.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.