Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court June 21, 1900 (Moore v. Wildey Casualty Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-06-1900

Morton, J.

This case comes here upon the defendant’s exceptions to the refusal of the court to give two rulings that were asked for. The first was that upon the evidence proper written notice of the accident was not given within the time limited by the certificate and that the defendant had not waived such notice, and the plaintiff could not, therefore, recover. The court refused to give this ruling, and ruled that proper written notice had not been given, but that there was evidence for the jury on the question whether the defendant had waived the requirement as to notice, • — ■ meaning, of course, the requirement as to the time within "which notice should be given. We think that this was correct. The accident occurred on March 31,1898. There was evidence tending to show that a brief notice of the accident, dated March 31, was sent by the plaintiff’s husband to the defendant company, but was not received till April 11. There was *421also evidence tending to show that another notice, dated April 9, and giving full particulars of the accident, was sent by the plaintiff’s husband to the company, but that this likewise was not received till April 11. No objection was then made by the company that these notices were not within the time required by the certificate. That fact would not of itself, perhaps, constitute sufficient evidence of waiver. But on April 23 the defendant’s secretary sent to the plaintiff ah accident blank, saying that she could fill it out and forward it to that office at her earliest convenience, if she so desired. A blank containing full particulars of the accident and signed by the plaintiff’s husband, and dated April 26, was received by the defendant, and has been retained by it without objection, so far as appears. Presumably this was the blank referred to in the letter of the defendant’s secretary of April 23. After the death of the plaintiff’s husband, on June 10,1898, a certificate was filled out by her and sent to the defendant company.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.