Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court November 28, 1900 (Berard v. Boston & Albany Railroad)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-11-1900
Hammond, J.
On this report the only question before us is whether the evidence would justify a finding by the jury that *180any physical injury except that caused by fright was done to the plaintiff.
The plaintiff was driving in a “ low down ” milk wagon across a grade crossing on a public street in Worcester, when the horse which he was driving was struck by a rapidly moving railroad train and killed, and the wagon demolished. The plaintiff and his son saved themselves by jumping from the wagon when the train was close to the horse. The plaintiff landed upon his feet, and he was not hit by the train. He testified that when he jumped out he was so near the train and the “ breeze was so hard” that it “ kind of twisted” him half way around or more, and that he felt dizzy and nervous at the time.
The accident occurred early in the morning, and the plaintiff testified that in the afternoon of the same day he went to bed, sent for a doctor, and was confined to the house about three weeks; and that during all that time he felt sick all through his body, ■— “ kind of pains in [his] side and heart,” and that he “ was troubled with [his] water a few days after that.” There was also evidence tending to prove that he was a well man before the accident, but that since that time his heart has been affected and he has been unable to attend to his business.
The plaintiff called his physician, who testified that he had attended the plaintiff frequently, and that in his judgment the cause of the plaintiff’s trouble was a “ shock to the nervous system ”; that the heart was weak, but that the witness could not find in the books any explanation of the cause of the weakness ; that the trouble with the heart was functional and not organic ; and that he should judge the plaintiff to be about forty-five or fifty years of age.
It did not appear that there were any bruises or other external signs of injury upon the plaintiff’s body.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit