New Mexico Supreme Court August 24, 1900, 868 (Lockhart v. Leeds)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-08-1900

PARKER, J.

Mining lanas: Spanish grant: location ol mines. 1. The question to be determined is whether the appellant has by his bill stated a case which entitles him to any relief in a court of equity. A suit in ejectment involving the same mining claim, which is the subject of this litigation, was before this court, and the opinion deciding it will be found reported under the title of Lock-hart v. Wills, 54 Pac. Rep. 336. The appellees contend that upon the allegations of the bill, the remedy of the appellant is at law, and not in equity. We think this contention is well founded, and that the action of the court in sustaining the demurrer was correct. In the case of Lock-hart v. Wills, supra, we held that the ground in controversy was subject to location under the mining laws of the United States. In that case it was stipulated by the parties that the decree of the Court of Private Land Claims, confirming the private land claim within which it was alleged the ground in controversy was located, eliminated the mine from the gra'nt. We held, however, that although that decree had not been rendered at the time the attempted locations of the “Sampson” and “Washington” mines were made, nevertheless, the ground was subject to exploration, location and entry under the mining laws of the United States. After fully discussing the contention of the parties and the law applicable to the facts, we said: “We conclude that they” (lands within unconfirmed Mexican or Spanish grants) “are not reserved lands and are 'lands belonging to the United States’ within the meaning of section 2319 of the Revised Statutes of the United States.” We deem it unnecessary to again discuss this question and refer to our opinion in that case.

Equity: pleading: demurer. The demurrer admits the truth of all the allegations in the bill which are well pleaded. If any of the allegations in the bill, however, are ambiguous, they are to be construed more strongly against the appellant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.