Hawaii Supreme Court May 4, 1900 (Pacific Hardware Co. v. Lincoln)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-05-1900
OPINION OF THE COURT BY
FREAR, J.
This is an action for $101 against defendant Lincoln, a contractor, personally and to enforce a materialman’s lien for this amount against a dwelling house and cottage owned by defendant Cooper. The jury found against Lincoln for the amount claimed and for the enforcement of the lien for $99.44,- — -a portion of the materials furnished,- valued at $1.56, having been shown not to have gone into the building. The case comes here on exceptions taken by defendant Cooper.
The exception chiefly relied on was taken to the refusal of the trial judge to allow defendant Cooper to show that the contract for the dwelling house was abandoned by the contractor and the building taken over by the defendant on the 26th of May and *359that the latter thereafter completed the building himself by day labor. The object stated at the time was to show that the notice of the lien was' not filed within ninety days after the completion of the building.
The statute provides (Civ. L. Sec. 1742) that, “The lien shall continue for three months, and no longer, after the completion of the construction * * * of the building * * * unless the same shall have been satisfied, or proceedings commenced to collect the amount due thereon by enforcing the same” and (Sec. 1744) that, “The lien herein provided shall have force only from the date of filing.” The contract was abandoned May 26, the notice of lien filed August 26, and the action commenced August 30. It is evident that the lien, to be effective, must have been filed not later than three months after the completion of the building, but it was so filed even if the building must be deemed to have been completed, within the meaning of the statute, as defendant contends1, on May 26. Defendant seems to have assumed that the time limited by the statute was ninety days, in which case, of course, the lien would not have been filed in time, if the building was completed on May 26.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit