Supreme Court of Alabama November 15, 1900 (Zirkle v. Jones)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1900

TYSON, J.

The first 'assignment of error is based upon tlie action of the court in sustaining' demurrers to tlie first and second counts of tfie complaint. Tliis assignment is not insisted upon in argument, and we will not notice it further. — 1 Brick. Dig. 102, § 285.

Amended count number 3 set out the contracts in haee verba upon which the plaintiff® relied for a recovery, averring a performance on the part of Tarlton and others, and a refusal on the part of defendant to pay the plaintiffs the sum claimed by them as due under the contracts. By the terms of the contract between plaintiff's and defendant, the defendant was to become liable to them only in the event of the completion of the contract by Tarlton and others with him. By the terms of the latter contract, Tarlton and other bound themselves to deliver a deed and also the property, to defendant, on or before the 5th day of October, 1899, free from all liens, incumbrances, taxes of any kind whatever.

Amended count 4 was a count for work and labor done by plaintiffs for-defendant.

To these two counts the defendant filed six pleas. The second was in this language: “That the only contract which defendant had with plaintiffs is shown by the third count of said complaint, and plaintiffs performed no work or labor for defendant except thereunder, and defendant avers tli-at at the time of the alleged offer to deliver said deed the property proposed to be conveyed was incumbered by a lien for State and county taxes and by a lien for city taxes which has not been discharged.”

There was no demurrer to this plea. It was treated as presenting a full and complete defense to the counts. To it the plaintiffs filed two special replications. A demurrer was sustained to each of these, and the ruling of the court in this respect is assigned as error here.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.