Supreme Court of Alabama November 15, 1900 (Marshall v. A. Shift & Son)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1900

SHARPE, J.

Complainant and her husband jointly gave defendants their negotiable note payable November 1, 1897, together with a mortgage on lands purporting *547to secure tlie note. , Slie sues for cancellation of the mortgage on the ground among others, that the land is her separate property and that, except as to a part of the debt which has been paid, the mortgage was given to secure a debt owing by her husband solely and is, therefore, void under the statute (Code, § 2529), which prohibits the wife to become surety for her husband’s debts directly or indirectly.

Among the defenses is a plea averring “these respondents hypothecated said note and mortgage foir full value to a bona fide purchaser who took no notice of the fact that complainant claimed said lands as her separ*ate estate.”

'There was undisputed evidence tending to show the land was complainant’s, that part of the consideration for the note was money borrowed for her, that the remainder was an account owing at the time by the husband solely, and that enough had been paid on the note to cover the borrowed money.

The proof without conflict shows James K. G-lennon acquired the note and mortgage by transfer from defendants on November 14th, 1898, to secure him against loss on account of an endorsement then made for defendants. After submission on pleadings and evidence, a decree was rendered in vacation unqualifiedly dismissing the bill. In his written opinion the chancellor gave in substance as his reason for such decree that the plea was sustained by the uncontradicted evidence, the effect of which, as entitling defendants to dismissal, would not be obviated by any amendment of the pleading’s.

We are of the opinion that the plea was not proven. As against the complainant and her asserted right, Glennon, having received his transfer after the note matured, is not shown to be a bona fide purchaser. With exceptions applying under some circumstances to accommodation paper (Connerly v. Planters, etc. Ins. Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.