Supreme Court of South Carolina March 30, 1900 (Riley v. Bank of Allendale)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-03-1900
The opinion of the Court was delivered by
Mr. Justice Pope.
The action was brought against the defendant bank for an accounting, and came on for hearing before his Honor, Judge Benet. By his decree he found the defendant was indebted to the plaintiff on the 3d day of' July, 1899, in he sum of $714.74, with interest from that date. The defendant has appealed from said decree on the following grounds: “1. Because his Honor, the presiding Judge, erred in finding as a matter of fact that defendant, without the knowledge or consent of the plaintiff, relaxed the terms and conditions of the first timber contract, by extending the time of payment upon Woodward giving additional security in the shape of chattel mortgage and stock in manufacturing company, and in holding that the defendant became liable to the plaintiff for the entire amount due by Woodward on said timber contract, whether the same was collected or not. 2. Because his Honor, the presiding Judge, erred in finding as matter of fact, that the sec.ond timber contract was not intended to replace the first contract, and covered timber not embraced in the first timber contract; whereas, he should have found that the second timber contract was intended to operate as a recision of the first contract and take the place thereof. 3. Because his Honor, the presiding Judge, erred in finding as matter of fact that the plaintiff claims, and that her contention is sustained by the evidence, that her indebtedness to the defendant on the 17th day of April, 1894, was $1,093.70. 4." Be*100cause his Honor, the presiding Judge, erred in finding as matter of fact that the plaintiff surcharged the defendant’s account, and that her objections to said account are well taken; whereas, his Honor should have found that the sworn statement of account introduced in evidence by defendant should be taken and deemed as a correct and true accounting until surcharged by the introduction of testimony to show error therein. 5.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit