Appellate Court of Illinois February 1, 1900 (Heggie v. Smith)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-02-1900

Mr. Presiding Justice Crabtree

delivered the opinion of the court.

Appellants brought this suit in assumpsit against appellees, to recover the price of seventeen iron “ skips,” amounting to $1,020, which skips were manufactured by appellants and delivered to Dion Geraldine, who was a subcontractor under appellees on the sanitary drainage canal.

Appellants were boiler-makers in the city of Joliet, and manufactured the skips in question upon an order given to them by Geraldine. Thus far there is no dispute, but the claim of appellants is, that the skips were delivered for the use and benefit of appellees, to be used by the latter in their work upon the main channel of the sanitary district of Chicago, upon which they were contractors.

The declaration contained only the common counts, and the only plea upon which the case was tried was the general issue.

A jury was waived and the cause tried by the court. The court found in favor of the 'defendants, and after overruling a motion for a new trial rendered judgment against the plaintiffs for costs, and they prosecute this appeal.

It appears from the evidence that, in July, 1892, the McCormick Construction Company became contractors to perform certain work upon a part of the main channel of the sanitary district, known as section 14.

Appellee succeeded to the rights of the McCormick Co. in their contract to this work. Geraldine became a subcontractor under appellees, to take out of the channel certain rock after it had been blasted. To perform this work he required the use of what are termed “skips,” which were fashioned like a large scraper, into which the stone, after being blasted, was thrown by hand, and then the skips and contents were lifted out upon the bank, and there the stone was discharged. These skips cost about $60 each, and quite a number were required in order to do the work.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.