Appellate Court of Illinois March 16, 1900 (McCormick Harvesting Machine Co. v. Haug)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-03-1900

Mr. Justice Bigelow

delivered the opinion of the court.

As appellant’s counsel say in opening their argument that they will not attempt to discuss in detail each error assigned, we shall content ourselves by following their example.

The correctness of each and all of appellees’ instructions given to the jury is challenged.

The first instruction is as follows :

“ The court instructs the jury that if the contract introduced in evidence in this case shows that in case the said McCormick Harvesting Machine Company, or their authorized general agent, find that any note taken and passed upon is doubtful and worthless at the time of the sale, then the said agents, Haug & Son, shall take the said note and replace it with cash, or note secured by good and responsible parties, that shall be acceptable by said company or their general agent, then it was the duty of the plaintiif in this case to return the notes of Hargus and McCoy or offer to return them before they brought suit against these defendants.”

The principal ground of objection to it is, that it did not tell the jury to whom the notes should have been returned. The attention of the jury is first called to the contract between appellant and appellees, which was in evidence before them, and it does not seem possible that the jury could have understood that if appellees were to pay appellant for the notes of Hargus and McCoy, that the notes were to be delivered to any person other than those who were to pay for them.

The delivery of the notes of Hargus and McCoy by appellant to appellees, and the payment for them in one of the ways provided in the contract, were dependant acts, to be simultaneously performed by each party.

The giving of the instruction was not error.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.