Appellate Court of Illinois July 31, 1900 (Lake Shore Sand Co. v. East Tennessee S. & M. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-07-1900

Mr. Justice Shepard

delivered the opinion of the court.

This was a suit in assumpsit by the appellee against appellant to recover for a quantity of manufactured marble contracted for, most of which was delivered, and a part of which was offered for delivery but its acceptance refused.

There was a verdict and judgment for the plaintiff (appellee), and this appeal has followed.

Mo instructions to the jury appear to have been asked by either party, and the court gave none on its own motion.

The questions argued by appellant are ones of fact, and such as concern the admission and rejection of evidence. The marble was ordered from appellee for use in the interior work of a county court house, in Indiana.

The agreements of the parties with reference to the marble were made by voluminous correspondence—telegraphic and by letter—and personal interviews between their respective agents, the whole forming a complicated and voluminous mass.

There were delays in furnishing the marble, and it would require a lengthy review of everything constituting the agreements of the parties, as well as a large amount of conflicting oral testimony, to tell whether such delays were excusable or not. The jury has found from the facts and circumstances shown in evidence that they were. Damages were claimed by the appellant that apparently were not allowed by the jury, and especially, for an amount paid by appellant for marble newels and hand-rails to take the place of some that were shipped by appellee and not accepted by appellant.

Extensive space would be required to discuss whether the facts justified the action of the jury in rejecting such claimed damages. We refer to these matters, and might do so as to others, in order to give prominence to the futility of burdening our opinion with a lengthy discussion that could only result in a conclusion that we may not in such matters of fact supplant the judgment of the jury by our own.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.