Appellate Court of Illinois October 10, 1900 (American Splane Co. v. Barber)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-10-1900
Mr. Presiding Justice Shepard
delivered the opinion of the court.
The declaration in assumpsit counted specially on the contract, and contained, also, the common counts. The trial was by the court and a jury, and a judgment’ for $1,097.92 was rendered upon a verdict for that amount.
It will be observed that the contract was for a period of one year, terminating JVIay 26, 1897. The suit was begun August 26, 1897. It will also be noticed that the contract is sealed.
Appellant’s preliminary point is that appellee can not maintain an action in assumpsit on a contract under seal to which she is not a party.
Assuming, as appellant does, that appellee is not a party to the contract, and also, that the contract is not only under seal, but is of a character requiring a seal, the rule at common law, and formerly in this State, would not have permitted her to maintain a suit upon it even though the contract was for her benefit. Moore v. House, 64 Ill. 162, and subsequent cases.
But since that case was decided the common law rule has been changed, on that subject, by section 19 of the practice act, and it is now immaterial, for the purpose of bringing the suit, whether the contract is under seal or not. Webster v. Fleming, 178 Ill. 140.
It needs, we think, only that the contract be read in order to show that appellee was benefited by it, and intended so to be.
It was agreed by E. A. Barber that his wife, the appellee, should pay appellant $1,000 on account of the stock of goods to be carried in the business, and that at the expiration of the contract appellant should repay to her the sum so paid by her. She agreed to the contract and invested the money on those conditions.
Whether or not, as discussed, the contract became terminated before the expiration of the year expressly provided for its ending, by reason of any default or breaches on the part of either the appellant or E. A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit