Appellate Court of Illinois October 23, 1900 (Pfirshing v. Heitner)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-10-1900

Mr. Presiding Justice Shepard

delivered the opinion of the court.

Appellee, as second indorsee, brought suit against appellants and others, as guarantors of a promissory note which, with the indorsements thereon, was as follows:

$500.

“ Chicago, November 20, 1890.

On or before nine months after date, for value received, The Western Gas Improving Co. promises to pay to the order of Peter Keller the sum of five hundred dollars, at No. 116 LaSalle street, with interest at the rate of six per cent per annum after date.

The Western Gas Improving Co.,

By Joseph Pfirshing,

President.

Jacob Portz, Sec.

[[Image here]]

(Indorsements on back of note are as follows:)

“ Chicago, July 17, 1891.

¡Received full amount of within note, from ¡D. Heitner,

Peter Keller.”

“ Chicago, September 28, 1893.

Pay to order of Babie Heitner without recourse.

David Heitner.”

“Joseph Pfirshing,

Joseph Des Jardins,

Jacob Portz,

Peter Keller.”

“ Pay to the order of David Heitner.

Peter Keller.”

Certain pleas and replications were filed which, in the language of appellants’ brief, closed “ the issue as to whether there was a guaranty or indorsement, as well as the time when such guaranty or indorsement was made.”

It was held in Kingsland v. Koeppe, 137 Ill. 341, that where a person who is not the payee of a promissory note, but a third party, places his name on the back thereof, the long-established rule in this State is, that it may be shown by parol evidence what liability was intended to be assumed by so doing.

And after citing cases the court continues :

“ From the cases cited it is apparent that this court is fully committed to the doctrine that where a third party writes his name across the back of a promissory note, the presumption from the indorsement is that he assumes the liability of guarantor. Yet parol evidence may be introduced to prove what liability was in fact assumed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.