Appellate Court of Illinois September 11, 1900 (Chicago & Alton R. R. v. Gore)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-09-1900
Mr. Justice Wright
delivered the opinion of the court.
This suit is by appellee against appellant to recover for the loss of a foot in consequence of the alleged negligence of the latter. A trial by jury ended in a verdict and judgment against appellant for $7,541.66f-, to reverse which this appeal is brought, and to effect such reversal it is insisted the verdict is unsupported by the evidence, the court refused to correctly instruct the jury, and gave to it improper instructions.
Appellee was a passenger upon the train of appellant, first from Chicago to Springfield, to which latter place he had checked his baggage. In transit he informed the conductor he desired to continue his passage to Carlinville, and requested the conductor to change his checks to the latter station, but this the conductor declined to do, at the same time informing the passenger he could do it himself, and upon inquiry informed him the change could be made at Joliet, Pontiac or Bloomington. Appellee alighted at Joliet for such purpose, saw the baggageman and there changed the destination of his baggage to Carlinville, and some delay having occurred in his transaction with the baggagemaster, the train moved before he again got upon it, and in the hurry to board the moving train he lost his balance, and while holding on the guards to the steps of the car platform was struck by a baggage truck standing upon the station platform, and was thus thrown under a wheel of one of the cars that crushed his foot.
We are asked to reverse the judgment because the court refused to give the jury the peremptory instruction for the defendant, but in the view we now have of the case, we are not so disposed, but think because of the error contained in the instructions, the judgment must be reversed and the cause remanded for a new trial.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit