Indiana Court of Appeals May 29, 1900, No. 3,132 (Everitt, Seedsman v. Bassler)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-05-1900
Henley, J.
—This was an action for damages growing out of the breach of contract. The first paragraph of complaint declares upon a verbal contract; the second upon a written contract.
Appellant, a'corporation, filed a written motion directed to each paragraph of complaint, asking that appellee be required to separate the causes of action, improperly joined therein, into paragraphs,' and number them, which motion the court overruled. Appellant’s demurrer was also overruled to each paragraph of complaint; thereupon appellant filed four paragraphs of answer addressed to each paragraph *304of complaint and a counterclaim in one paragraph. Appellee replied the general denial. The cause was submitted to the court for trial, which resulted in a judgment for appellee. Appellant’s motion for a new trial was overruled.
The first question presented to this court arises out of the ruling of the lower court in overruling appellant’s motion to require appellee to separate the causes of action improperly joined in each paragraph of complaint into paragraphs and to number them. It is not necessary that we examine into the merits of this motion, as the ruling of the court in any event was not available error and could not result in a reversal of the judgment. It would seem that the cases cited by appellant’s counsel were directly in point, but the later decisions of the Supreme Court, are squarely in conflict with the rule contended for by counsel. See Wabash, etc., R. Co. v. Rooker, 90 Ind. 581; Mansfield v. Shipp, 128 Ind. 55; Richwine v. Presbyterian Church, 135 Ind. 80; Shaw v. Ayres, 17 Ind. App. 614.
The next question arises upon the ruling of the lower court in overruling the demurrer to each paragraph of complaint.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit