Supreme Court of Iowa February 7, 1900 (Plano Manufacturing Co. v. Farrell)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-02-1900

lead-opinion

Given J.

2 *5813 4 *5825 *579I. Prior to the harvest of 1891 the defendant purchased from the plaintiff a Plano- binder, with the usual -warranty and agreement on the part of the plaintiff, on notice, to put the binder in order if it did not do good work. On account of -this purchase, the defendant executed and delivered his two promissory notes to the plaintiff. On the twenty-first of April, 1894, the defendant executed and delivered to W. N. Smith, plaintiff’s collecting agent, the note sued upon, and received from him said two> promissory notes and the written agreement set out in the answer. Defendant’s contention is that said written agreement to put the binder “in good working order before the harvest of 1894” was the sole- consideration for the- note in suit, and that the plaintiff failed to put the binder in good working order before that harvest, wherefore he says the consideration for the note wholly failed. The plaintiff claims that this note was given in renewal of, and in con*580sideration for the surrender of, said two promissory notes, and therefore contends that the consideration has not failed. Defendant testified as follows: “I quit farming in March, 1895. I had this binder four years, — during the years 1891, 1892, 1893, and 1894. I bought it about three weeks before the harvest of 1891, and cut my grain with it that year and the next-year. I also cut my grain with it during the years 1893 and 1894. In 1891 I cut a lot of my neighbor’s grain with this machine. I cut for Chris Bannon. I do- not know just how much I cut. I never measured it. I do not remember of cutting for any one else that year. I cut for Duffy One year. I cut about ten acres of flax. I cut for Diehard McCabe one year. I think it was in 1894. I cut about fifteen acres of oats. I cut for Jas. Brady one year. I. do not know how many acres. I cut flax for Pat Duffy. I think it wasinl892.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.