Supreme Court of Iowa February 8, 1900 (Nelson v. Nederland Life Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-02-1900
Ladd, J.
1 The policy was, by its terms, based on the ■ application of the assured, which stipulated that, in event any of its statements proved untrue, the contract should be null and void. This application formed a part of the policy, and amounted to a warranty of the truthfulness of the statements made, and it is not material that some of the answer may have been unimportant. The parties, having agreed to their materiality, set that inquiry at rest. Hygum, v. Insurance Co., 11 Iowa, 25; Miller v. Insurance Co., 31 Iowa, 225; Miles v. Insurance Co., 3 Gray, 580; Insurance Co. v. France, 91 U. S. 510 (23 L. Ed. 401); Powers v. Association, 50 Vt. 630; McCoy v. Insurance Co., 133 Mass. 82; Dewees v. Insurance Co. 34 N. J. Law, 244; Cushman v. Insurance Co., 63 N. Y. 404; Insurance Co. v. Raddin, 120 U. S. 183 (7 Sup Ct. Rep. 500, 30 L. Ed. 644); Macdonald v. Insurance Co., L. R. 9 Q. B. 328. If the insured consulted a physician, even though for a disease other than that from which death resulted, or from apprehension of having some ailment, the defendant was interested in knowing the fact, that further investigation might be made. By the answers that none had been seen, it may have been induced to refrain from doing so. The information as to whether'the insured had had. occasion to resort to medical *603aid, however, would seem of no little importance to a company about to take a risk on the extent of his life, and, if false in this respect, there appears no ground, in the absence of statutory enactment, for upholding a contract based thereon. As directly in point, see Cobb v. Association, 153 Mass. 176 (26 N. E. Rep. 231, 10 L. R. A. 666); Insurance Co. v. McTague, 49 N. J. Law, 587 (9 Atl. Rep. 766).
2 II. The defendant set up in its answer the falsity of the answers of the assured contained in the- application as a breach of warranty, and relied thereon to defeat recovery on • policy.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit