Supreme Court of Iowa October 4, 1900 (Mereness v. First National Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-10-1900

Ladd, J.

*131 *12In the early case of Bean v. Briggs, 1 Iowa,. 488, this court held a time certificate of deposit, in the usual form, negotiable, for that it possessed all the characteristiesof a promissory note. Story defines a “promissory note”' *13to be “a written engagement by one person to pay another person, therein named, absolutely and unconditionally a certain sum of money at a time specified therein.” Story, Notes, section 1. The ordinary certificate of deposit is precisely within this definition, and it is generally held that such certificates are, in effect, promissory notes, and governed, with certain exceptions, by the same ■rules. Klauber v. Biggerstaff, 47 Wis. 551 (3 N. W. Rep. 357) ; Bank v. Brown, 45 Ohio, St. 39 (39 Am. St. Rep. 527) ; Institute v. Weedon, 18 Md. 320 (81 Am. Dec. 603) ; note to O’Neill v. Bradford, 42 Am. Dec. 575; 5 Am. & Eng. Enc. Law (2d ed.) 803, and cases collected. The decisions reaching a contrary conclusion seem to rest on the peculiar wording of particular certificates. See Patterson v. Poindexter, 6 Watts & S. 227, 40 Am. Dec. 554; O’Neill v. Bradford, supra. The exceptions referred to relate to the necessity of a demand before suit may be maintained or the statute of limitations begins to run. The cases so holding seem to rest on the theory that the transaction not alone creates a ■debt against the drawer of the certificate, but is also in the nature of a bailment, — in contemplation of law a deposit, and not a loan, — and hence that demand is essential before the holder is entitled to the return of his money. Payne v. Gardiner, 29 N. Y. 146 (divided court) ; Bellows Falls Bank v. Rutland Co. Bank, 40 Vt. 377; Brown v. McElroy, 52 Ind. 404; Munger v. Bank 85 N. Y. 580; McGough v. Jamison, 107 Pa. St. 336; Schute v. Bank, 136 Mass. 487.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.