Supreme Court of Iowa October 17, 1900 (Finnegan v. City of Sioux City)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-10-1900

Waterman, J.

Plaintiff, while carrying a package to put in the buggy of a friend, who had stopped in the street a short distance from the curbstone,- stepped into a hole in the driveway and fell, causing the injuries for which he sues.

1 *2342 *233I. Plaintiff had a right to go upon-the driveway of the street for the purpose he did. If his injuries were caused by a defect that rendered the driveway unsafe for usage as such, certainly the city would be liable. Lamb v. City of Cedar Rapids, 108 Iowa, 629; Baker v. City of Grand Rapids, 111 Mich. 447 (69 *234N. W. Rep. 740). There was evidence Lending to show that the hole into which plaintiff stepped was near the sidewalk line; that it was about three feet long, four to six inches wide, and eight inches deep, and at the time of the accident was filled with slush caused by melted snow. The trial court was also warranted in concluding that the defect had existed for-some three months prior to the accident, and that the city had notice thereof. The finding that defendant was negligent was manifestly justified. The defect, if such as shown by the evidence to which we have referred, was dangerous to those using the street for driving purposes.

8 II. Was plaintiff guilty of contributory negligence? The time of the accident was between 7 and 8 o’clock of a November evening. There were lights in adjacent stores, and a street lamp near by was burning. Plaintiff did not know of the existence of this hole, although he was well aware that the street paving was rough. The package he was carrying was a heavy jar of butter. He was proceeding as one ordinarily would under the circumstances. Rearing in mind that it was not negligence per se for him to walk in the street where he did (Baker v. City of Grand Rapids, supra), we must hold that the question of his negligence was one of fact, and the finding of the trial court has the force and effect of the verdict of a jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.