Supreme Court of Louisiana June 15, 1900, No. 13,395 (Canedo v. New Orleans & Carrollton Railroad)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1900
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Blanchard, J.
Plaintiff, a young Spanish girl, seeks to hold defendant responsible in damages for injuries inflicted upon her by being struck by one of the street cars of the company.
*2150' Allegations of fault, negligence and recklessness of the company and its agents, usual in- damage suits, are made.
Her injuries are described, the pain and suffering she underwent delineated, the medical and surgical treatment she received outlined, and the length of time she was laid up given.
It is also averred that her injuries are serious and permanent, her general health impaired, her nervous system disordered, arid her ability to earn a livelihood lessened. She lays her damages at $5,000.00, with $50.00 additional for medicines, etc.'
The defense ascribes the accident and injury which befell plaintiff to her own fault and gross contributory negligence.
The case was tried by jury, and a verdict of $500.00 returned in favor of plaintiff, two jurors of the panel dissenting.
Defendant appeals.
It is urged here that the verdict on its face bears evidence that it was not a deliberate conclusion reached on the evidence administered, but a sentimental verdict wrung from a sympathetic jury, and an intimation in argument ascribes this to the hypnotic influence exerted upon susceptible jurors by the presence before them of the comely young plaintiff.
This view, or part of it, seems to find corroboration in the observations of the trial judge denying the application for a new trial. He said: “I am more than doubtful whether a new trial should not be allowed. The amount of the verdict is very small. I am much of the opinion it was extorted from the sympathy of a jury making free with other people’s money.'' I may 'be' mistaken in this view, and it seems imprudent for a single individual, acting in a case of this kind, to disturb the finding of a jury of twelve men.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit