Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit April 3, 1900, No. 137 (Jackson v. Knapp)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-04-1900

Mr. Chief Justice Alvey

delivered the opinion of the Court:

This appeal is from the Patent Office, and the case is one of interference between the claim of .the appellants, William S. Jackson and Louis P. Perew, and that of the appellee, John D. Knapp, in regard to an improvement in handles for velocipedes. The issue of interference as formulated in the Patent Office, is as follows:

“A velocipede handle or grip of substantially ellipsoidal form, consisting of an inflatable bulb extending lengthwise of the grip, and provided in its lower portion with a groove or recess, and a rigid concave supporting plate arranged along the under side of the bulb and provided at its edge with a retaining lip or flange which engages in the groove or recess of the bulb.”

The facts are few and simple, and seem to admit of little or no controversy. The appellee, Knapp, is the senior party to the interference, having filed his application in the Patent Office on the 15th of August, 1896. He filed a preliminary statement, though he took no testimony in support thereof, and he therefore stands on the record date of his application, and the constructive reduction to practice that follows therefrom.

The appellants, Jackson and Perew, the junior parties to the interference, filed their application on the 26th of May, 1897, more than nine months after the application of Knapp was filed. They filed a preliminary statement and produced evidence in support thereof. They allege in their preliminary statement that they conceived the invention involved in the interference, and explained the same to others, in the month of February, 1896; that they made a sketch or drawing of the invention in the month of March, 1896; but that they made no model of the invention, and have not reduced the same to practice. They stand, therefore, upon a mere constructive reduction to practice, by the filing of their application on May 26, 1897.

*340From the proof taken on the part of Jackson and Perew, .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.