Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York May 11, 1900 (Reeve v. McMann)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-05-1900
lead-opinion
PATTERSON, J.
There are two causes of action set forth in the complaint herein. The first is upon a promissory note made by the defendants’ testator, Edward Flanagan, and dated January 2, 1893, by which the maker promised to pay, six months after the date thereof, to the order of Mary E. Flanagan or C. C. Reeve, the sum of $1,000. For a second cause of action the plaintiff declared upon a promissory note made by the defendants’ testator, Edward Flanagan, and dated May 11, 1897, by which the maker promised to pay, six months after the date thereof, to the order of Mary E. Flanagan or C. C. Reeve, $1,000. After the action was brought, the note set forth in the second cause of action was paid by the defendants. The case proceeded upon the first cause of action only, as to which the defense interposed and insisted upon at the trial was payment. There was no direct evidence of the fact of payment of the first note, but the defendants undertook to establish that "by a series of renewals of the first note, running along from the date of the maturity of that note to the date of the note set forth in the second cause of action, the indebtedness represented by the first note was continued until it was finally extinguished by the payment of the last in the series of renewals, namely, the note declared upon in the second cause of action. On the trial the plaintiff introduced in evidence the note dated January 2, 1893, and rested, whereupon the defendants undertook to prove the affirmative defense; They produced and put in evidence a number of promissory notes for $1,000 each, signed by Edward Flanagan, and made to the same payees as the note of-January 2, 1893, all of which notes, it is claimed, were renewals of the note set *684out in the first cause of action. That note matured July 5, 1893.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit