Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 9, 1900 (Carville v. Roosevelt)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-07-1900
GOODRICH, P. J.
On November 5, 1891, the plaintiff, being the owner of 61 lots of land at New Rochelle, conveyed them to one Stagg for the consideration of $9,500. 'Stagg, on November 21st, conveyed one undivided half to the defendant, and in May, 1893, when Stagg became insolvent, the other undivided half. The defendant has sold about one-half of the lots, and the remainder stand in his name *579and are unsold. He has received on such sales about §11,000. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant was her attorney in the transaction, and concealed from her the fact that he was jointly interested in the transaction with Stagg at the time of the purchase; that she handed him the deed for the purpose of carrying out the understanding between the parties, which, as she testified, was that §2,000 was to be paid in cash, and §7,500 was to be left on mortgage, and that Stagg was to build" two houses for her on other lots which she owned, and that the price therefor was to be paid by the defendant out of the §2,000 and a sum of §1,000, which he had in his hands, belonging to her. It appeared that the houses were built and paid for, and it was conceded that there had been paid to the plaintiff different amounts, so. that there was left unpaid of the purchase money the sum of §5,150 on May 5, 1898. The defendant’s counsel at the trial stated that that amount was due the plaintiff from the defendant, and that the latter had offered, and was ready and willing, to give a bond and mortgage on that part of .the property remaining unsold, or on any other property which he owned. The court, on sufficient evidence, has found that the defendant was not the agent or attorney of the plaintiff; and we must regard the transaction as an ordinary one between vendor and vendee, without any fiduciary relation. The court found, as conclusions of law, as follows:
“First. That by reason of the conveyances made by the plaintiff to Charles F. Stagg, and by Charles F.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit