Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York December 14, 1900 (Farrell v. City of Middletown)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-12-1900
GOODRICH, P. J.
The plaintiff was digging a trench for a sewer in Middletown, when he was injured by the caving in of the sides. There was testimony that the trench was in filled-in ground, and was from 6 to 9 feet deep, 7 feet wide at the top, and sloping down to a width of 3 or 3-3,- feet at the bottom. No sheathing planks were furnished by the city, nor any means of shoring up the sides, and no evidence was given that the trench required sheathing, or that there was any apparent danger,. except, possibly, the evidence of Mr. Bowler, an alderman and the chairman of the sewer committee, by trade a hatter, who told Wilcox, the foreman of the job, prior to the accident, that the trench needed sheathing; but he did not testify to the fact that sheathing was necessary, or to any circumstances from which such a conclusion could be derived-, and there is abundant evidence that there was no appearance of danger. Neither the plaintiff, nor his witnesses who were at work with him, saw any danger. The work was in charge of Harris, the city engineer, who was examined as a witness on a former trial, but not on the last trial, owing to his absence in Porto Rico. It was admitted by the plaintiff’s counsel that he was a “competent engineer.” The court nonsuited the plaintiff.
The only possible question arises from the fact that Bowler told Wilcox that the place needed sheathing or shoring with jackscrews, but as Harris was a competent engineer, and his foreman, Wilcox, had had considerable experience in the construction of such trenches, I think they were better qualified to see danger than the aider-man hatter. Moreover, as the plaintiff had been digging trenches for three or four years, and as neither he nor his co-laborers saw any danger till the accident occurred, I do not see that any negligence in the same respect can be imputed to the city.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit