Michigan Supreme Court November 13, 1900 (Watson v. Kent Circuit Judge)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-11-1900

Long, J.

A petition was filed in the circuit court by the petitioner praying that she might be allowed to take an appeal from certain orders of the probate court, to wit, from an order allowing the final account of Charles D. Lyon, as executor of the estate of Truman H. Lyon, *183deceased; also from an order directing the distribution of the residue of said estate, and determining the rights of the respective parties therein; also from an order discharging said Charles D. Lyon from his trust as executor of said estate. Upon the filing of this petition the executor answered, denying the right of the petitioner to an appeal from such orders, for the reasons, among others, that more than 60 days had elapsed since the -allowance of his final account by the probate court and his discharge as such executor; that all the facts pertaining to said account were fully and completely known to said petitioner at the time they, respectively, took place; and that the petitioner is of mature age, and of competent judgment, and was present in the court at the time the final account of said executor was examined and allowed, and consented thereto, and was represented by attorneys in good standing, competent to advise her.

The circuit court made an order denying the right of appeal, saying, “I cannot find that justice requires a revision of the case.” Application is now made to this court for a mandamus directing said circuit judge to forthwith set aside such order, and instead thereof to make an order allowing said petitioner, on reasonable terms, to appeal from said orders of the probate court. An order to show cause was issued from this court, and the circuit judge has made return thereto, stating his reasons why the order theretofore made by him should not be set aside.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.