Supreme Court of Minnesota July 11, 1900, Nos. 12,051—(172) (Moldenhauer v. Minneapolis Street Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-07-1900

START, C. J.

The plaintiff, about midnight on September 7, 1898, was riding his bicycle along the right-hand roadway of Hennepin avenue, in the city of Minneapolis, when his wheel struck a small stone in the (path, whereby he was thrown over his handle bars onto the west line of defendant’s street-car track. He was rendered unconscious by the fall, and while he so remained on the track he was struck by one of the defendant’s electric cars, and his left leg broken in two places above the knee, and in one place below the knee. He brought this action to recover damages for such injuries on the ground of the negligence of the defendant in so running the car upon him. He had a verdict for $3,750. The defendant made a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, or for a new trial, as provided by the statute (Laws 1895, c. 320), and appealed from an order denying its motion.

The plaintiff, in his complaint and on the trial, claims that the defendant was negligent in at least three particulars, which were the cause of the injury: First, that it negligently maintained the headlight on the car which struck the plaintiff, and permitted it to become defective, dirty, and grimy, so that it would not and did not give a sufficient light upon the defendant’s tracks at the time of the accident; second, that the car was, at the time, being run at a dangerous rate of speed; third, that the motorman, after he discovered the plaintiff lying on the track, or might have done so by the exercise of due care, failed to use ordinary care to stop the car and protect him from injury. The defense was a denial of all negligence on the part of the defendant, and a countercharge of contrib*428utory negligence by tbe plaintiff. Tbe trial court submitted all three of the plaintiff’s claims, as to the defendant’s negligence, to the jury, to which neither party excepted.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.