Supreme Court of Minnesota July 19, 1900, Nos. 12,164—(208) (Rustad v. Bishop)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-07-1900
COLLINS, J.
That this is a case in which plaintiffs’ attorneys have attempted to oppress the defendant by means of legal process is very evident, when we state the facts..
The defendant, a laboring man with a family, a resident of the city of Duluth, became indebted to the plaintiffs in a sum exceeding $50. Suit was brought against him September 8, 1899, and at the same time the garnishee company, for whom defendant worked as a teamster, was served with a summons in the garnishment proceedings, returnable September 18. At the hearing the garnishee disclosed an indebtedness of $31.50, and defendant claimed an exemption, under G. S. 1894, § 5314, of $25. This claim was allowed, but the balance, $6.50, was improperly paid upon the judgment which had been entered against the defendant in the original action. See Sheehan v. Newpick, 77 Minn. 426, 80 N. W. 356.
*499October 9 a second affidavit in garnishment was filed, and a garnishee summons issued and served upon the same company. This was made returnable October 23. The plaintiffs made no effort to serve notice upon the defendant, and for that reason no disclosure was made; but at this time the garnishee was owing the defendant, as wages, $12.25, all of which was exempt under the statute. No further proceedings were had in this garnishment. On October 24 the plaintiffs filed a third affidavit in garnishment, and caused another summons to be served upon the same company, returnable December 4. Notice was served upon the defendant, and it appeared from the disclosure that the indebtedness to him on account of wages had increased $6.27; the total indebtedness tjien being $18.52. No further steps were takqn, according to the record. November 3 the plaintiffs filed a fourth affidavit in garnishment; the summons being returnable December 4,1899. No notice of this proceeding was given to the defendant, and, at plaintiffs’ request, no disclosure was made. At this time the defendant had earned $8.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit