Supreme Court of Minnesota November 14, 1900, Nos. 12,323—(40) (Hoit v. Berger-Crittenden Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-11-1900
START, G. j.
Tbe defendant demurred to tbe complaint in this action, and appealed from an order overruling the demurrer.
Tbe second subdivision of tbe complaint, standing alone, states a cause of action. But tbe defendant claims that tbe allegations of tbe third subdivision of tbe complaint show that tbe cause of action alleged in tbe second subdivision has been conclusively adjudicated adversely to tbe plaintiff by arbitration. The allegations of tbe two subdivisions of tbe complaint must be read and construed together, and if, when so read, it appears that tbe alleged cause of action has been so arbitrated, tbe complaint does not state a cause of action; if otherwise, it does.
Tbe allegations of tbe second subdivision of tbe complaint were to tbe effect that tbe parties entered into a contract whereby it was agreed that tbe plaintiff should purchase and ship to defendant, in its name, such wheat and grain as be might determine upon, tbe *357defendant paying the purchase price; that when the grain was sold the profits should be divided equally between the parties; that what was designated as a “joint cash wheat account” was opened in the books of the defendant, and a record made therein of the transactions of such joint enterprise; that such business was carried on by the parties for two years, when the contract was terminated, at which time the profits, as shown by the account, amounted to $1,956, which was in the hands of the defendant, one-half of which — $978— belonged to the plaintiff; that the defendant refused to pay it, although it was duly demanded.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit