Supreme Court of Minnesota November 14, 1900, Nos. 12,434—(47) (Mathews v. Great Northern Railway Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-11-1900
START, C. J.
The plaintiff’s intestate, Thomas P. Mathews, was killed by the derailment of a construction train upon which he was riding, which was operated and controlled by the defendants Guthrie & Co. This action was brought against them and other parties by the widow of Mr. Mathews, as administratrix of his estate, to recover damages resulting from his death, which was caused, as the complaint alleges, by the negligence of the several defendants. At the close of the evidence the trial court directed a verdict for all of the defendants except Guthrie & Co., hereafter designated as the defendants, and submitted the cause to the jury as to them. Verdict for the plaintiff for $5,000, and the defendants appealed from an order denying their motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, or for a new trial.
The assignments of error logically fall into three general groups: First. Did the trial court err in its rulings as to the' admissibility of evidence? Second. Did it err in its instructions to the jury? Third. Is the verdict sustained by the evidence?
1. The defendants were engaged as contractors in building for the *365Eastern Railway Company of Minnesota a railway line about one hundred miles long between Deer River and Fosston, in this state. They sublet the grading to various parties, the track-laying to Brennan & Son, and the bridge and culvert work to the firm of Mathews & Keith, of which the plaintiff’s intestate was a member. The defendants operated a construction train to aid in the execution of the work, but the track-laying and bridge firms hired their own men, and paid them for their services. The contract between the defendants and Mathews & Keith provided that the defendants should supply all timber and iron on the cars for the bridges at the most convenient points, free of charge, but the bridge contractors were to take the timber and iron from the cars.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit