Supreme Court of New Jersey November 19, 1900 (Wallace, Muller & Co. v. Leber)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-11-1900
*198The opinion of the court was delivered by
Magie, Chancellor.
On behalf of defendants it is first contended that there was an entire failure to prove any consideration for the contract sued on.
An examination of the conclusions of the trial judge seems to indicate that this point was not presented to him, for no mention of it is made by him. Hone of the exceptions allowed by him are pointed at this supposed defect of proof. An exception, however, was allowed to the finding that plaintiffs were entitled to recover $1,545.46, with interest, from defendants, on the ground that there was no evidence to warrant it.
If the issues had been tried with a jury, an exception that the verdict was not sustainable because there was no evidence to warrant it, would have been unavailable on error. To • raise such a question on error, the trial judge must have been requested to nonsuit, or to direct a verdict for defendant, because of the lack of some specified proof essential to recovery. The precise point relied on must have been presented to the mind of the trial judge, and ruled on by him. This doctrine, and the reasons for it, are stated in this court in Trade Insurance Co. v. Barracliff, 16 Vroom 543. It has been applied for like reasons by the Supreme Court in the review of verdicts upon rules to show cause. Jackson, Administrator, v. Consolidated Traction Co., 30 Id. 25.
It is entirely settled that, upon error, the finding of the trial judge trying the issue without a jury is as unassailable as the verdict of a jury would be, and the judgment founded thereon cannot be reversed if there was evidence capable of supporting the finding. Weger v. Delran, 32 Vroom 224, and eases cited.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit