Tennessee Supreme Court January 10, 1900 (Kimmell v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-01-1900

Caldwell, J.

G. E. Kimmell is under conviction for selling goods in Robertson County without having paid a privilege tax and obtained a license, as required by the revenue laws of the State.

He admits that he made the sales as charged, but insists that in doing so he was engaged in interstate commerce, and that he was, therefore, not subject to taxation under State laws. This defense, if true in fact, is conclusive in law, and, as a consequence, the conviction, is erroneous if the defendant was really engaged in interstate commerce.

Kimmell testified that he sold the goods' by sample to citizens of Springfield, in Robertson County, Tennessee; that he made the sales as the agent, and subject to the approval of the L. B. Price Mercantile Company, of Kansas City, Missouri ; that he forwarded his orders to a branch house of his principal at Lexington, Kentucky, from which he received the goods ordered, and then delivered them to the purchasers.

This testimony, considered alone, malees a plain case of interstate commerce. It shows commercial transactions between citizens of different States, and such transactions constitute interstate commerce, *186which, though conducted by an agent, cannot be subjected to the burden of taxation under State laws. State v. Scott, 98 Tenn., 254, and citations.

But there is other evidence in the record amply justifying the judgment of the Court below.

Though Kimmell testified that he made the sales and forwarded the orders as agent, and • that he received and delivered the goods in that capacity only, the bill for the goods, as copied into the record, shows that they were consigned and charged to him individually, and without reference to the persons to whom he sold them.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.