Tennessee Supreme Court October 8, 1900 (Minnis v. Abrams)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-10-1900

McAlister, J.

This bill was filed to collect balance due on a promissory note and to enforce vendor’s lien for same on tract of land in Hamilton County.

The principal controversy in the case was wheth*663■er the note was barred by the statute of limitations. The note was for $400. It was dated in 1886, and the bill was not filed until 1898. Complainant relied on a new promise made by a letter 'written to complainant by the maker of the note, in which he assured him the statute of limitations should never run against the debt and lien. The maker of the note died, and this bill was filed ■against his widow, heirs, and devisees to enforce the vendor’s lien and collect the note. An administrator ad litem was appointed and made a party defendant to this bill. This was, therefore,a suit between the complainant and the administrator of the estate, and the statute forbidding either party to testify in respect of communications and transactions with the deceased would apply. The Court of Chancery Appeals excluded all testimony by the complainant as to communications and transactions with deceased, but held that it was competent for complainant, although a party to the case, to testify to the independent fact that he had this letter in his possession, and that it was in the handwriting of his uncle, the deceased maker of the note. The section of the code referred to is as follows, viz.: “In actions or proceedings by or against executors, administrators, or guardians, in which judgment may be rendered for or against them, neither party shall be allowed to testify against the other as to any transactions with or statements by the testator, intestate, or *664ward, unless called to testify thereto- by the opposite party.” Shannon’s Code, § 5598.

The policy of the statute is to provide that when one of the parties to a litigated transaction is silenced by death the other shall be silenced by law. Wharton on Evidence, Vol. 1, sec. 466.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.