Ohio Supreme Court May 8, 1900 (Dueber Watch Case Mfg. Co. v. Daugherty)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-05-1900

Minshall, J.

These questions arise upon the case: 1. Did the agreement to transfer give to the plaintiffs any equitable interest in the stock? 2. If so, was their equity superior in merit to that of the company? 3. Did the assignment of the stock made January 7, 1892, with knowledge of the claim of the company, give them a superior right to the latter, though the equities were equal? 4. Can the company, under the circumstances disclosed by the answer, be heard to make a claim to the stock against an innocent third person?

1. At the time the parties became sureties for Co-burn and Dulaney, Coburn agreed that the stock he then held should be transferred as security to them against loss; and this induced them to become sure*593ties on the note. The promise was a written one as follows: “The collateral described by Mr. Dulaney will be turned over to Mr. Michner at any time desired — this week. (Signed) John A. Coburn.” We do not, however, attach any importance to the fact that it was in writing, beyond the fact that it indicates with certainty the agreement of the parties. It is not necessary, as we think, to determine whether this agreement constituted a present pledge of the stock. Strictly speaking, stock being of an incorporeal nature, is not capable of being pledged, as there cannot be a delivery of intangible property. It may be, and frequently is, hypothecated, which is a pledge in a secondary sense. An hypothecation is defined as a right which a creditor has over a thing belonging to another, and which consists in a power to couse it to be sold, in order to be paid his claim out of the proceeds. Bouvier Law Die. “Hypothecation.” Whatever the agreement between the parties should, in legal propriety, be termed, it was such an agreeihent.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.