Ohio Superior Court, Cincinnati July 1, 1900 (Samuel Wymond Cooperage Co. v. Thompson)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-07-1900
Wright, J.,
Jackson and Dempsey, JJ., concur.
The facts found at special term are in all respects sustained by the evidence: the court was right therefore, in its finding of a warranty, in its assessment of the amount of the damages, as well as in its determination that Thompson, defendant in error, had not in his treatment of | the barrels been negligent,
j Whiskey barrels manufactured by The Wymond Cooperage Company had, to the number of several thousand, been sold and delivered to John B. Thompson, a distiller, under a warranty that they were “of first class white oak timber thoroughly seasoned and charred, free from worm holes, seed holes, knots, dottings and other imperfections, and all of first class ’ workmanship; and guaranteed to hold the whiskey as well as any first class barrels that could be made.” At the trial it was in issue that the barrels were deficient in respect to material and workmanship, so that much whiskey was lost through leakage.
By way of establishing the goodness and soundness of the barrels in question the Cooperage Company undertook to prove the goodness and soundness of other barrels manufactured and sold during the same season, to other distillers; supplementing this by offer of proof that this other cooperage “was made out of the same character and kind of timber that was furnished to Thompson and the wood was cut at the same time and that it was made by the same character of machine and that the entire manufacture and supervision in the inspection of the staves as originally cut and before being put into the barrels and after put into the barrels was exactly the same as in Mr. Thompson’s case; and to show further that the barrels that were sent to Squibb & Co. were made and billed out and shipped without reference to the time, that they were put into the cars, and shipped without discrimination in the choice of barrels that were sent to Mr. Squibb or Mr. Thompson.” (Offer of proof, bill of exceptions p. 506.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit