United States Court of Claims April 30, 1900, No. 21417 (Nelson v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-04-1900
Nott, Ch. J.,
delivered the opinion of the court:
It is plain in this case that the money was paid in mutual mistake of fact. Both parties supposed that the claimant’s entry in the land office covered and described the land which he had improved and was living upon. In that belief the claimant paid the. purchase money and the Government issued its certificate. When it was discovered that the mistake of a single numeral had transferred the entry to an adjoining section of land the Government canceled the entry but did not *430repay the purchase money. In equity and good conscience it is bound to do so.
The court does not mean to hold that the action of the Commissioner of the Land Office and of the Secretary of the Interior was erroneous. An executive officer has a limited statutory authority, and can disburse or refund public moneys only in cases where he is expressly authorized so to do. In this court a cause may be one of legal right, though no executive officer be empowered to satisfy it. In this case it seems indisputable that the Government in equity and good conscience is bound to refund this money; and in such a case the action for money had and received will lie.
The statute of limitations is set up, and the question arises, When did the claim first accrue? If this was an ordinary transaction of debtor and creditor it might be said that it accrued when the mistake was discovered. But in this case the claimant supposed that the mistake would be remedied by allowing him to amend the terms of his original entry. Accordingly he did not demand back the purchase money, but applied first for the other relief, the correction of the original entry. The application was overruled. In the meanwhile the money remained in the hands of the defendants, being in the nature of a pledge for the amended certificate if one should be issued. The claimant next applied for the return of the purchase money. That application was also overruled.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit