Utah Supreme Court April 11, 1900 (Thum v. Pingree)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-04-1900
After stating the facts,
Miner, J.,
delivered the opinion of the court.
The record shows that a receiver was appointed for 0. Bunting & Co., bankers, in the State of Idaho, but not in the city of New York, and that such appointment in Utah was not made until long after the warrants had been attached in New York City.
Under the authorities it is clear to our minds that where a receiver has been appointed, or property has been transferred by operation of law, such receiver has no extra territorial jurisdiction over property, except that which is found within the territorial limits of the State wherein he was appointed, and such transfers have no force upon property outside of such State where they are made, and it will be administered for the benefit of creditors and others interested therein by courts of that State where it is found. Osgood v. Maguire, 62 N. Y., 524; Bank v. Lacombe, 84 N. Y., 367; Wood v. Parsons, 27 Mich., 159; Blake v. Williams, 6 Pick., 286; Paine v. Lester, 44, Conn., 196; Pierce v. Obrien, 129 Mass., 53.
The principal question for determination, then, is, Were *358the county warrants issued by, and showing indebtedness of, Bingham and Fremont Counties, Idaho, owned • by C. Bunting & Co., bankers, a corporation, and by it transferred to and actually held by the Chase National Bank of New York City as a pledge to secure the payment of the note of C. Bunting & Co., liable to attachment in the courts of New York, by the creditors of C. Bunting & Co., who also resided in New York, without personal service of summons on the counties issuing the warrants and obligated to pay the same ?
Sec.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit