Supreme Court of North Carolina December 20, 1901 (State v. Welch.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-12-1901

*580

Clark, J.

The defendant is indicted fox practicing medicine or surgery without license. The bill is drawn under section 5, Chapter 181, Laws 1889, and is a

verbatim

copy of the indictment which was sustained in

State v. VanDoran,

109 N. C., 864. The defendant moved

to

quash the bill, and also in arrest of judgment, because:

1. It did not negative the provision of the statute allowing persons to pursue the avocation of midwifery.

2. The bill fails to allege the defendant practiced for “fee or reward.”

3. The bill alleges defendant “unlawfully and wilfully did practice or attempt to practice medicine or surgery,” and the offense of practicing and attempting to practice are so distinct that the charge is not 'set forth in “a plain, intelligent and explicit manner.”

4. That the words “register and obtain” license should be in the bill, and not merely a failure to obtain license.

The motion being overruled, the defendant excepted. The provision as to’ the exception of “women practicing as midwives” is in the

proviso,

and instead of constituting a part of the offense, withdraws a eei’tain. class

from

its operation. Hence, the bill need not negative the defendant belonging to that class. That would be a matter of defense, and, indeed, it affirmatively appears in the evidence that the defendant is not a woman.

This statute does not contain the words “without fee or reward.” The first two exceptions are passed upon and denied in

State v. Call,

121 N. C., 643. The third exception is fully discussed and held invalid in

State v. VanDoran, supra.

The words excepted to in the fourth ground of defendant’s motion are copied from the bill in VanDoran’s ease, which was cited again in

State v. Call, supra,

which case says “an approved form of indictment under the act of 1889 may be found in

State v.

VanDoran.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.