Supreme Court of North Carolina April 23, 1901 (Howe v. Hall.)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-04-1901
MONTGOMERY, J.
This case was tried at the August Special Term, 1900, of the Superior Court of Gaston County, before
Starbuck,
J., and a jury. After the plaintiff had introduced his evidence, each of the defendants made a motion for judgment dismissing the complaint as of nonsuit upon the ground that the evidence had disclosed the fact that neither of the defendants was the corporation, or the representative of the corporation, which had inflicted the injury complained of by the plaintiff, and that the injury had in fact been inflicted by a corporation which had not been sued. The motion was refused, but was renewed when all the evidence on both sides had been introduced. His Honor, desiring further time for the purpose of examining certain records con
*168
■stituting a part of the evidence, before deciding the motion, the counsel agreed at his Honor’s suggestion that the issues of fact be submitted to the jury and answered by them without prejudice, and that the question of law as to the liability of any or all of the defendants, raised by the motion, should be reserved for the subsequent determination of the Court out of term time.
The issues were therefore submitted to the jury, and they found that the “person or persons operating the Chester and Lenoir Railroad Company on March 31, 1894,” had negligently injured the plaintiff to the extent of $500.
On the 18th day of September thereafter, Judge
Starbuclc
reudered the judgment set out in the record, in which it was adjudged that the defendants were not liable to the plaintiff for the damages assessed by the jury; that the plaintiff take nothing by this action, and that the defendants go without •day.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit