Supreme Court of Alabama November 20, 1901 (Wimberly v. Montgomery Fertilizer Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-11-1901

HARALSON, J.

— The bill was filed to sett aside alleged gifts or conveyances of property by II. T. Wim-berly to his wife, Ó. P. Wimberly, because they were voluntary, without consideration and void as to the complainant and existing creditors of said H. T. Wim-berly.

1. A conveyance which is purely voluntary, not tainted with an actual intent to hinder, delay and defraud creditors, is void only as to existing creditors, but when'tainted with actual fraud, is void as to subsequent, as well as to existing creditors.—Dickson v. McLaren, 97 Ala. 383, 388; Seals v. Robinson, 75 Ala. 363. Only constructive fraud is alleged in the bill. The burden was on complainant to establish the existence *110of debts by H. T. Wimberly to him at the time of said alleged conveyances; and if he bought property and paid for it with his own money, taking the title in the name of his wife, the conveyance was fraudulent and void against existing creditors.—Yeend v. Weeks, 101 Ala. 301; Peevey v. Cabaniss, 70 Ala. 252.

2. It is alleged that H. T. Wimberly, on March 1, 1893, while indebted to complainant, was the owner of a large number of shares in the Opelika Compress Company, a corporation, and that on the 1st of March, 1893, he transferred twenty-five shares of stock owned by him in said company to his wife, C. P. Wimberly, which transfer was wholly voluntary, without consideration and void as against complainant and other creditors of said I-I. T. Wimberly.

It is also alleged, that at the same time he owned a half interest in a store house in Opelika, known as the Lightfool store; that on the 17th November, 1894, he pretended to convey the same to his brother, T. P. Wim-berly, apd on the 26th December, 1894, the said T. P. Wimberly conveyed the same to C. P. Wimberly, the wife of said I-I. T. Wimberly, and that both of said deed's were voluntary and without consideration, — the one to said T. P. Wimberly having been executed with the understanding between him and said H. T.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.