Supreme Court of Colorado April 15, 1901, No. 4090 (Cheney v. Crandell)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1901

lead-opinion

Chief Justice Campbell

delivered the opinion of the court.

1. Apparently both parties concede that the respective tax deeds under which they hold are invalid, so that element of the controversy is eliminated from the present discussion.

2. It seems that the judge in vacation, of his own motion, ordered the cause transferred from the district court of Costilla to the district court of Conejos county. Whether this ruling was right is not material here, for the court had jurisdiction of the subject matter and when the cause was called for trial in the district court of Conejos county the plaintiff waived the objection by voluntarily appearing and consenting to proceed with the trial.

3. The point is made that the cause, or causes, of action set out in the complaint are legal causes of action, and that therein equitable defenses, such as this answer contains, are not permis • sible; and to this proposition we are cited to Smith v. Pipe, 3 Colo. 187, 195; Wells v. Caywood, 3 Colo. 487, 495; and Stephens v. Clay, 17 Colo., 489. The first two eases were decided under the modified common law practice prevailing in this jurisdiction before our code of civil procedure was adopted. The last ease cited with approval the case of Wells v. Caywood, but not as to the point now under consideration. That an equitable defense may be interposed to a legal cause of action, including what under the old practice is denominated ejectment, is clear under section 59 of our code, and has been expressly declared in Lewis v. Hamilton, 26 Colo. 263.

4. The record shows that after the first judgment in favor of plaintiff was entered upon the verdict of the jury, a motion by defendant for a new trial for cause was filed, and the same was overruled, and the defendant prayed an appeal which was never perfected.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.