Supreme Court of Colorado September 15, 1901, No. 4162 (Ault v. Ault)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1901

Chief Justice Campbell

delivered the opinion of the court.

This is an action for divorce. The wife in her complaint charges her husband with desertion, which he denies in his answer, and therein and byway of cross-complaint, alleges cruelty and desertion by her, *150When the proof was in the court instructed the jury that defendant’s evidence was not sufficient to sustain his charge of cruelty, and thereupon withdrew the same from their consideration. The cause was then submitted under the complaint and cross-complaint upon the respective charges of desertion, and the jury found against the plaintiff and in favor of the defendant to the effect that she had been guilty of the desertion charged by him. This writ of error is sued out by the plaintiff to review the judgment,

A number of questions have been argued by counsel, but as we think that the judgment is wrong, the only assignment of error considered is that the verdict is not sustained by the evidence. In Johnson v. Johnson, 22 Colo. 20, it was said:' “Desertion consists in the actual ceasing of cohabitation, and the intent in the mind of the offending party to desert the other.” In i Bishop on Marriage and Divorce, § 1662, et seq., practically the same definition is given. It is clear under our statutes and under the authorities that there is no desertion unless there is an intent upon the part of the one charged therewith permanently to break off the marriage relation, or where there is a justification for the separation in the consent of the alleged wronged party.

The plaintiff and defendant were married in the state of Illinois in the year 1888, and soon afterwards removed to Denver in Colorado. The wife was in delicate health at the time of her marriage, and from time to time suffered from nervous hysteria. In 1893, acting on the advice of a physician, and with the consent of her husband, she returned to Illinois, where she visited her relatives until September, 1897.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.