Appellate Court of Illinois July 12, 1901 (Joliet Railroad v. McPherson)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-07-1901
Mr. Justice Waterman
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an action to recover damages on account of a personal injury alleged to have been suffered by appellee through the negligence of appellant.
It is conceded that as to the question of negligence the controverted fact is, did appellee, who was a passenger upon appellant’s car, remain on" the car until it stopped, and was he thrown down because of the sudden starting of the car while he was in the act of getting off, or did he attempt to get off before the car stopped at the street intersection ?
As to this question the evidence was variant, and not such that this court can say that the jury and the trial judge were mistaken and that a verdict for the defendant should have been rendered. The plaintiff has recovered a judgment for $3,500 and it is insisted that such amount is excessive. Appellee is—or was at the time of the injury—about sixty-eight years of age; by profession a photographer. At the time of the trial his left leg was so shrunken in size that it was from an inch and a half to two inches and a half less in circumference than corresponding measurements on the right limb showed it to be; his left leg was very stiff, with a great deal of thickness and hardening about the hip joint. The testimony of his regular physician is that the probabilities are that appellee, at his time of life, will never recover from the injury. He is now so lame as to be obliged to use crutches, his injured limb being of little, if any, use to him. The surgeons of appellant, by whom he was treated after the jury, diagnosed the case as one of a sprain, and at the trial expressed the opinion that the shrinking of the limb was due to the disuse of it; but they .failed to say that the injury is not permanent, or was not serious, nor do they deny that appellee suffered, as he claimed, great pain.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit