Michigan Supreme Court December 3, 1901 (People v. Lindgren)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-1901

Hooker, J.

The defendant appeals from a conviction upon a charge of-keeping his saloon open on a Sunday. *695Many of the questions raised are to remarks of the court in the course of the trial. As the case can be disposed of upon another point, it is unnecessary to discuss them.

Ford Barnett was a witness called upon behalf of the people. The prosecutor sought to refresh his recollection by reading to him his testimony taken upon the preliminary examination. He was then asked:

“Q. Now, is that affidavit the truth?

“A. My signature is to it.

“Q. I ask you if it is true, — the whole of it.

“A. I swore to it.”

The testimony was then offered in evidence and admitted. He afterwards testified that he could not swear that the occurrence was upon Sunday, or that he swore that it was upon Sunday, and that any testimony that he gave on the last trial was from the knowledge obtained from reading the depositiqn.

After being out for a time, the jury returned, and the following occurred:

“ The Court: Gentlemen, is there some question that bothers you, — a question of fact or a question of law, was it?

“ A Juror: The main question was whether that affidavit that was read here, whether that stood all right the way it was sworn to, — if that was satisfactory testimony.

“ The Court: Whether it was evidence or not?

“The Juror: Yes, sir.

“The Court: Yes, sir; I so instructed you.

“ The Juror: That is what I thought.

“ The Court: Was that all, gentlemen ?

“ The Juror: That is all.”

Counsel for the prosecution relies upon the cases of People v. Butler, 55 Mich. 409 (21 N. W. 385); Lightfoot v. People, 16 Mich. 507; People v. Kennedy, 105 Mich. 436 (63 N. W. 405). In each of these cases the deposition of the witness was admitted by way of contradiction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.