Supreme Court of Minnesota December 20, 1901, Nos. 12,725-(119) (Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance v. Sun Insurance Office)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-12-1901

LEWIS, J.

The principal question involved in this case has been considered and determined in N. W. Mut. Life Ins. Co. v. Rochester German Ins. Co., supra, page 48. The policies cover the same building, the same issues were presented in the pleadings, and the court submitted the question of total loss to the jury upon the saíne theory. The decision in the former case therefore controls this action. Certain evidence, however, as to the value of materials in the walls and the cost of rebuilding, was offered by the insured for the bearing it might have upon the question of total loss, and, .as those particular questions were not presented in the other case, it will be necessary to give them attention here.

The court properly rejected the evidence in reference to the value •of the brick after they had been taken from the wall, cleaned, •and made ready for use again. We need not repeat what was said in the other case, that the insurance was upon the building, and not upon the materials composing it; hence it was of no importance what the brick might be worth after renovation and preparation for rebuilding. They do not remain a part of the building if taken from the walls, and in the process of their removal the building is to that extent completely destroyed.

For the purpose of applying the test laid down in the former case, it was proper to show the value of the walls remaining, in place, as compared with the total cost of rebuilding, and the cost of repairing the walls suitable for that purpose; and for the purpose of showing the value of such walls, in place, after repair, it was competent to show what the cost of erecting new walls would be. The question for the jury to determine was, as of the date of the ñre, what a prudent owner, desiring to rebuild, would do under *67the circumstances, — would he reconstruct, using the walls remaining, in place, or would he build anew from the foundation?

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.