Ohio Supreme Court April 16, 1901 (Board of Education v. Guy)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-04-1901

MinshaUj, O. J.

It appears from the record that the common pleas held that the demurrer was well taken on the ground that the petition does not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action, entitling the plaintiff to relief, and overruled it on the. other grounds. On error the circuit court simply affirmed the judgment. We are of the opinion that the judgment should be affirmed on the ground that the plaintiff has no right to maintain the action. It *445is. true that the board of education is made by statute a body corporate with capacity to sue and be sued; but capacity to sue is one thing, and right to maintain a particular action is another thing. The plaintiff has no right to maintain this action, and. the second ground of demurrer is well taken; and might probably have been raised without demurrer. See Buckingham v. Buckingham, 36 Ohio St., 68, 78, where it is said: “To warrant a recovery on the petition, it must show a cause of action in the plaintiff. If the petition fails to show such cause of action, the objection is not waived by a failure to demur, or to make the objection by answer.” It is said in High on Injunctions, section 573: “The governing rule, resting alike upon principle and authority, is that the action to enjoin the collection of a tax should be brought by the taxpayer, whose property and interests are directly affected by the tax which it is sought to enjoin, the same degree of interest being requisite as in all other cases where the extraordinary aid of equity is invoked.” A board of education is not a taxpayer; taxes may be levied for its benefit, but it pays none. Section 3973, Revised Statutes. It has then no interest in the subject of the action, nor is it any part of its duty to prosecute it. Thus it is said in Moody v. Arthur, 16 Kas.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.