Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit April 9, 1901, No. 723 (Kessler v. Inks)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-04-1901

GROSSCUP, Circuit Judge.

The action helow was to restrain the infringement of Letters Patent No. 562,895, issued June 28, 1896, to A. C. Gruhlke and W. P. Kessler. The improvement covered by the patent is a cigar lighter, of the suspended order, so arranged that the movement of the handle in the act of lighting the cigar ignites, automatically, through an electrode, the wick, and, by means of a .tight chamber, extinguishes the wick, when the handle is released and drops into its place.

The cigar lighter charged as an infringement is practically of the same character, and operates in the same way; but is defended as a permissible adaptation of Letters Patent No. 492,913, issued March 7, 1893, to J. C. Chambers. In this latter patent both ignition and ex-tinguishment of the flame is automatic.

In Eldred v. Kessler, 106 Fed. 509, the question was the counterpart of the one now before us, viz., whether a- cigar lighter constructed after the patent issued to Kessler was an infringement of the Chambers patent.

Both these patents, together with others illustrating the art, are set out at large in-the opinion in that case, and will not be reproduced here.

We held in that case that the prior art disclosed cigar lighters accomplishing the same genéral result as the Chambers and Kessler patents; and by analogous means, including the use of electricity; that, in at least one instance of the prior art, ignition was automatic; and that the means for extinguishing the flame, though not automatic, were convenient and effective; and we concluded that the invention of Chambers (and the same must be true of Kessler’s) was in no sense generic.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.