District Court, E.D. New York April 16, 1901 (The Stephen Decatur)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-04-1901

THOMAS, District Judge.

On the night of July 8, 1899, one of three scows in tow of the tug Stephen Decatur came in collision with the starboard bow of the schooner Sarah D. Fell, which was anchored in the neighborhood of Craven Shoal, south of the Narrows, in the Lower Bay, New York. For the injury thus done this libel was filed. The collision occurred about 2 o’clock in the morning. ' Craven Shoal is opposite Gravesend Bay. To the Avestward of a line drawn from Craven Shoal to Fort .Tomkins Light, and from such shoal to the south of buoy No. 11, are the western anchorage grounds. There are also anchorage grounds oh the east side of the channel, opposite Gravesend Bay. The captain of the tug states that he was accustomed to go either to the westward of the shoal, hence through the anchorage grounds, or to ihe eastward of the shoal, where the main part of the channel lies. He also states that he did not know that the water lying to the westward of the shoal was anchorage grounds, but assumed that they were to the eastward, in the location already stated. He states that it was the purpose of the tug at the time in question to go to the eastward of the shoal. The channel proper all lies east of Craven Shoal, and is about half a mile wide, and on each side of it the waters are devoted to anchorage purposes. The captain of the tug was not in the pilot house, and had not been from Owl’s Head, which is in the neighborhood of the Bay Ridgé Club house, some two miles and a half away; but the navigation was in charge of the pilot, who stated that he avus steering S. -J: E., and it appears that he was on the Staten Island or west side, because the ebb tide tended to set the vessels loAvards the east bank.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.